Skip to main content

Table 1 Clinical characteristics of the included studies

From: Melatonin or its analogs as premedication to prevent emergence agitation in children: a systematic review and meta-analysis

Study

Sample size

ASA

Age

Sex (M/F)

Type of surgery

Anesthetic agents

Postoperative analgesia

Melatonin dosage

Diagnosis tool for EA

Control

Foundation

Ali [11] 2020

105

1 to 2

3 to 8 years

91/14

Elective infraumbilical surgical procedure

Induce: propofol + fentanyl+atracurium;

Maintain: sevoflurane + N2O;

Paracetamol

0.2 mg kg− 1

Watcha scale

Dexmedetomidine or clonidine

Not mentioned

Jangra [10] 2022

120

1 to 2

3 to 9 years

75/45

Ophthalmic surgery

Induce: sevoflurane+fentanyl;

Maintain: sevoflurane + N2O;

Fentanyl for postoperative pain rescue

0.5 mg kg− 1

PAED scale

Dexmedetomidine

Departmental funds

Kain [22] 2009

148

1 to 2

2 to 8 years

82/66

Outpatient elective surgery

Induce: sevoflurane + N2O;

Maintain: not mentioned;

Not mentioned

0.05, 0.2, 0.4 mg kg− 1

Keegan scale

(3-point scale)

Midazolam

Not mentioned

Khalifa [23] 2013

60

not reported

3 to 6 years

31/29

Not reported

Induce: sevoflurane + cisatracurium;

Maintain: sevoflurane;

Paracetamol

0.1 mg kg− 1

Five-point scale

Placebo (saline)

Not mentioned

Komazaki [15] 2020

48

1 to 2

18 to 119 months

37/11

Tonsillectomy

Induce: sevoflurane + N2O +fentanyl+rocuronium;

Maintain: sevoflurane;

Paracetamol

0.1 mg kg− 1

PAED scale, Aono’s scale

Placebo (syrup)

National Funds

Ozcengiz [24] 2011

100

1 to 2

3 to 9 years

50/50

Oesophageal dilatation procedures

Induce: sevoflurane + N2O+vecuronium;

Maintain: sevoflurane + N2O;

Paracetamol

0.1 mg kg− 1

EAS

(4-point scale)

Placebo (saline),  midazolam, or dexmedetomidine

Not mentioned

Samarkandi [7] 2005

75

1

2 to 5 years

50/25

Minor elective surgery

Induce: sevoflurane + N2O;

Maintain: sevoflurane + N2O;

Paracetamol + caudal block

0.1, 0.25, 0.5 mg kg− 1

Pain/discomfort scale

(0 to 6 points)

Placebo (acetaminophen)a or midazolam

Departmental funds

Singla [9] 2021

132

1 to 2

3 to 8 years

93/39

Elective ambulatory procedure

Induce: sevoflurane + N2O + fentanyl;

Maintain: sevoflurane + N2O;

Fentanyl or regional block if required

0.3 mg kg− 1

Watcha scale

Placebo (honey) or midazolam

Departmental funds

Song [25] 2020

163

1 to 2

2 to 6 years

99/64

Elective adenotonsillectomy or adenoidectomy

Induce: propofol + fentanyl + succinylcholine;

Maintain: sevoflurane + N2O

Ketorolac

0.5 mg kg− 1

PAED scale

Placebo (syrup) or midazolam

Not mentioned

  1. a. In this study, melatonin or midazolam was orally administered mixed with acetaminophen, and the researchers identified oral acetaminophen alone as the placebo comparator
  2. Abbreviations: ASA, American Society of Anesthesiologists; PAED, Pediatric anesthesia emergence delirium; EAS, Emergence Agitation Scale