Skip to main content

Table 3 The sensitivity analysis of shoulder pain score at 24 h after operation

From: Pulmonary recruitment maneuver reduces the intensity of post-laparoscopic shoulder pain: a systematic review and meta-analysis

Removed sutdy

MD

95% CI

Z value

P value

I2

Güngördük K. [26]

–1.33

(–1.58, − 1.08)

10.36

< 0.001

48%

Kiyak H. [34]

–1.51

(–1.81, − 1.20)

9.66

< 0.001

77%

Lee J. [28]

–1.45

(–1.74, − 1.12)

9.88

< 0.001

78%

Sharami SH. [30]

–1.43

(–1.73, − 0.51)

9.06

< 0.001

80%

Davari-Tanha F. [25]

–1.56

(–1.81, − 1.31)

12.36

< 0.001

62%

Khanna A. [27]

–1.45

(–1.75, − 1.15)

9.46

< 0.001

81%

Phelps P. [17]

–1.45

(–1.85, − 1.06)

7.25

< 0.001

80%

Tsai HW. [32]

–1.46

(–1.75, − 1.16)

9.62

< 0.001

80%

Tsai HW. [31]

–1.46

(–1.75, − 1.16)

9.58

< 0.001

81%

Ryu K. [35]

–1.44

(–1.74, − 1.14)

9.41

< 0.001

81%

Ryu KH. [29]

–1.43

(–1.74, − 1,13)

9.31

< 0.001

81%

Tsai HW. [36]

–1.44

(–1.73, − 1.14)

9.43

< 0.001

81%