Skip to main content

Table 2 The sensitivity of shoulder pain score at 12 h after operation

From: Pulmonary recruitment maneuver reduces the intensity of post-laparoscopic shoulder pain: a systematic review and meta-analysis

Removed study

MD

95% CI

Z value

P value

I2

Güngördük K. [26]

–0.94

(–1.58, − 0.31)

2.93

0.003

86%

Kiyak H. [34]

–1.15

(–1.66, − 0.65)

4.48

< 0.001

88%

Sharami SH. [30]

–0.99

(–1.48, − 0.51)

4.02

< 0.001

89%

Davari-Tanha F. [25]

–1.42

(–1.76, − 1.09)

8.33

< 0.001

74%

Khanna A. [27]

–1.07

(–1.55, − 0.58)

4.34

< 0.001

90%

Phelps P. [17]

–1.00

(–1.75, − 0.25)

2.62

< 0.001

90%

Tsai HW. [32]

–1.17

(–1.63, − 0.71)

4.95

< 0.001

89%

Tsai HW. [31]

–1.15

(–1.63, − 0.68)

4.77

< 0.001

89%