Average force for 2 cm displacement (N) | ||||||||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
SolidAIRity® | Thomas™ | Anchor Fast | Tape & Mallinckrodt | Twill & Mallinckrodt | Tape & Securisyn tube | Twill & Securisyn tube | ||||||||
Test point | Mean | Standard deviation | Mean | Standard deviation | Mean | Standard deviation | Mean | Standard deviation | Mean | Standard deviation | Mean | Standard deviation | Mean | Standard deviation |
1 | 209 | 0.00 | 31 | 7.70 | 96 | 6.79 | 85 | 26.69 | 50 | 13.59 | 107 | 23.11 | 50 | 6.79 |
2 | 175 | 12.84 | 58 | 26.69 | 83 | 2.57 | 61 | 20.55 | 47 | 2.57 | 82 | 11.19 | 73 | 2.57 |
3 | 90 | 6.79 | 55 | 5.14 | 46 | 2.57 | 82 | 9.26 | 50 | 10.27 | 79 | 28.25 | 62 | 8.90 |
4 | 172 | 13.59 | 65 | 5.14 | 71 | 4.45 | 96 | 11.19 | 55 | 15.62 | 93 | 4.45 | 61 | 5.14 |
5 | 74 | 18.52 | 82 | 2.57 | 65 | 2.57 | 67 | 0.00 | 50 | 6.79 | 68 | 2.57 | 83 | 2.57 |
6 | 193 | 2.57 | 68 | 11.19 | 86 | 6.79 | 98 | 19.39 | 40 | 0.00 | 108 | 28.94 | 79 | 2.57 |
7 | 162 | 13.59 | 85 | 7.70 | 70 | 6.79 | 82 | 20.06 | 44 | 0.00 | 79 | 13.59 | 99 | 13.59 |
8 | 200 | 30.82 | 98 | 7.70 | 92 | 5.14 | 132 | 5.14 | 50 | 5.14 | 96 | 16.84 | 55 | 6.79 |
9 | 113 | 22.83 | 58 | 7.70 | 67 | 4.45 | 67 | 27.06 | 40 | 7.70 | 89 | 20.38 | 80 | 4.45 |
10 | 156 | 4.45 | 68 | 2.57 | 59 | 2.57 | 65* | 13.59 | 39 | 2.57 | 61* | 18.52 | 52 | 6.79 |
11 | 225 | 9.26 | 53 | 4.45 | 73 | 2.57 | 83* | 29.62 | 65 | 2.57 | 102* | 31.14 | 64 | 6.79 |
12 | 224 | 2.57 | 85 | 20.38 | 89 | 4.45 | 77* | 14.30 | 49 | 23.11 | 92* | 21.02 | 59 | 5.14 |
13 | 148 | 5.14 | 71 | 4.45 | 62 | 8.90 | 64* | 11.19 | 36 | 0.00 | 65 | 9.26 | 64 | 5.14 |
Average | 165 | 11.00 | 67 | 8.72 | 74 | 4.66 | 81 | 16.00 | 47 | 6.92 | 84 | 16.73 | 68 | 5.94 |
Average force for 5 cm displacement or failure (N) | ||||||||||||||
1 | 215 | 6.79 | 82 | 12.84 | 147 | 15.41 | 144 | 21.02 | 129 | 24.77 | 138 | 27.06 | 145 | 40.36 |
2 | 203 | 26.81 | 83 | 18.52 | 130 | 6.79 | 95 | 2.57 | 104 | 31.56 | 120 | 33.58 | 245 | 11.77 |
3 | 233 | 16.84 | 96 | 11.19 | 129 | 0.00 | 136 | 5.14 | 99 | 12.84 | 179 | 16.84 | 197 | 28.94 |
4 | 234 | 13.59 | 113 | 11.19 | 153 | 24.50 | 175 | 24.50 | 120 | 22.24 | 175 | 6.79 | 202 | 21.94 |
5 | 234 | 20.06 | 129 | 8.90 | 178 | 35.31 | 163 | 21.02 | 87 | 12.84 | 154 | 33.97 | 199 | 35.95 |
6 | 212 | 13.59 | 101 | 9.26 | 86 | 43.66 | 128 | 5.14 | 87 | 14.30 | 142 | 42.90 | 190 | 24.50 |
7 | 218 | 11.77 | 133 | 4.45 | 190 | 25.68 | 162 | 6.79 | 107 | 19.39 | 193 | 31.56 | 227 | 29.17 |
8 | 228 | 21.02 | 130 | 5.14 | 165 | 29.17 | 157 | 2.57 | 130 | 28.94 | 194 | 32.18 | 176 | 56.50 |
9 | 231 | 8.90 | 99 | 9.26 | 130 | 6.79 | 87 | 22.39 | 85 | 30.82 | 128 | 26.06 | 254 | 32.08 |
10 | 251 | 15.62 | 99 | 26.06 | 123 | 11.19 | 65 | 13.59 | 133 | 4.45 | 61 | 18.52 | 205 | 4.45 |
11 | 283 | 12.84 | 93 | 16.04 | 99 | 30.28 | 83 | 29.62 | 126 | 10.27 | 102 | 31.14 | 258 | 31.14 |
12 | 289 | 4.45 | 136 | 20.06 | 98 | 11.77 | 77 | 14.30 | 86 | 9.26 | 92 | 21.02 | 135 | 13.59 |
13 | 273 | 17.98 | 135 | 25.29 | 83 | 5.14 | 64 | 11.19 | 90 | 12.84 | 122 | 17.98 | 128 | 20.06 |
Average | 239 | 14.64 | 110 | 13.71 | 132 | 18.90 | 118 | 13.83 | 107 | 18.04 | 138 | 26.12 | 197 | 26.96 |