Study (Reference) | Year | Type of surgery /procedure | Patient age range & ASA status | Patients enrolled (Gender: F/M, n) | Intranasal Midazolam dose | Intranasal Ketamine dose | Scale used for sedation measurement | Outcomes |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Richard A et al.[18] | 1993 | Dental extraction | 17–62 mo, Not mentioned | 20 (Not mentioned): 1. Midazolam group: 10 2. Ketamine group: 10 | 0.4 mg/kg | 3 mg/kg | 10-points scale | I, III, V(a) |
Kazemi AP et al.[19] | 2005 | Elective surgery | 2–5 yr, ASA I-II | 90 (Not mentioned): 1. Midazolam group: 50 2. Ketamine group: 40 | 0.2 mg/kg | 5 mg/kg | 4-points scale | I |
Gharde P et al.[13] | 2006 | Elective corrective surgical procedure | 1–10 yr, Not mentioned | 40 (15/25): 1. Midazolam group: 20 2. Ketamine group: 20 | 0.2 mg/kg | 10 mg/kg | 4-points scale | I |
Gautam SN et al.[20] | 2007 | Elective surgery | 1–6 yr, ASA I-II | 50 (Not mentioned): 1. Midazolam group: 25 2. Ketamine group: 25 | 0.2 mg/kg | 5 mg/kg | 4-points scale | I |
Hosseini Jahromi SA et al.[14] | 2012 | Elective surgery | 2–8 yr, ASA I | 60 (32/28): 1. Midazolam group: 30 2. Ketamine group: 30 | 0.2 mg/kg | 3 mg/kg | 6-points scale | I |
Mostafa G et al.[21] | 2013 | Bone marrow biopsy and aspirate | 2–8 yr, ASA II | 64 (Not mentioned) 1. Midazolam group: 32 2. Ketamine group: 32 | 0.2 mg/kg | 5 mg/kg | 4-points scale | I, IV |
Surendar MN et al.[22] | 2014 | Dental treatment | 4–14 yr, ASA I | 42 (Not mentioned) 1. Midazolam group: 21 2. Ketamine group: 21 | 0.2 mg/kg | 5 mg/kg | 5-points scale | I, II, III, IV |
Narendra PL et al.[23] | 2015 | Various surgical procedures | 1–10 yr, ASA II | 100 (Not mentioned) 1. Midazolam group: 50 2. Ketamine group: 50 | 0.2 mg/kg | 5 mg/kg | 5-points scale | I, II, V(b,c) |
Fei et al.[24] | 2017 | Surgery for pediatric tumors | 1–3 yr, ASA I-II | 60 (23/37): 1. Midazolam group: 30 2. Ketamine group: 30 | 0.2 mg/kg | 5 mg/kg | 4-points scale | I, III, IV |
Akçay ME et al.[25] | 2018 | Ear nose throat surgical procedures | 1–10 yr, ASA I-II | 40 (14/26): 1. Midazolam group: 20 2. Ketamine group: 20 | 0.2 mg/kg | 5 mg/kg | 6-points scale | I, IV |
Milesi C et al.[15] | 2018 | Non-emergent endotracheal intubation | 24–36 weeks, Not mentioned | 60 (25/35): 1. Midazolam group: 27 2. Ketamine group: 33 | 0.2 mg/kg | 2 mg/kg | 4-points scale comprises three domains | I, II, IV |
Alp H et al.[26] | 2019 | Transthoracic echocardiography | 9–36 mo, Not mentioned | 139 (Not mentioned): 1. Midazolam group: 70 2. Ketamine group:69 | 0.2 mg/kg | 4 mg/kg | 4-points scale | I, IV, V(b,c) |
Jafarnejad S et al.[27] | 2020 | Obtaining peripheral Intravenous (IV) line in emergency care | 2–8 yr, ASA I-II | 70 (35/35): 1. Midazolam group: 35 2. Ketamine group: 35 | 0.2 mg/kg | 5 mg/kg | Observational Scale of Behavioral Distress-Revised (zero to 23.5) | I, IV |
Khoshrang H et al.[28] | 2021 | Urologic elective surgeries | 2–6 yr, ASA I-II | 71 (Not mentioned): 1. Midazolam group: 35 2. Ketamine group: 36 | 0.5 mg/kg | 5 mg/kg | 5-points scale | I, III, V(b,c) |
Verma I et al.[29] | 2021 | Elective cardiac surgery | 1–12 yr, ASA II- III | 60 (23/37): 1. Midazolam group: 30 2. Ketamine group: 30 | 0.2 mg/kg | 5 mg/kg | 5-points scale | I, IV, V(b) |
Abusinna RG et al.[30] | 2022 | minor elective surgical procedures | 2–9 yr, ASA I-II | 100 (52/48): 1. Midazolam group: 50 2. Ketamine group: 50 | 0.2 mg/kg | 2 mg/kg | 6-points scale | I, II, IV |