Skip to main content

Table 1 The general characteristics of the enrolled studies

From: Efficacy and safety of intranasal midazolam versus intranasal ketamine as sedative premedication in pediatric patients: a meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials

Study (Reference)

Year

Type of surgery /procedure

Patient age range & ASA status

Patients enrolled (Gender: F/M, n)

Intranasal Midazolam dose

Intranasal Ketamine dose

Scale used for sedation measurement

Outcomes

Richard A et al.[18]

1993

Dental extraction

17–62 mo, Not mentioned

20 (Not mentioned):

1. Midazolam group: 10

2. Ketamine group: 10

0.4 mg/kg

3 mg/kg

10-points scale

I, III, V(a)

Kazemi AP et al.[19]

2005

Elective surgery

2–5 yr, ASA I-II

90 (Not mentioned):

1. Midazolam group: 50

2. Ketamine group: 40

0.2 mg/kg

5 mg/kg

4-points scale

I

Gharde P et al.[13]

2006

Elective corrective surgical procedure

1–10 yr, Not mentioned

40 (15/25):

1. Midazolam group: 20

2. Ketamine group: 20

0.2 mg/kg

10 mg/kg

4-points scale

I

Gautam SN et al.[20]

2007

Elective surgery

1–6 yr, ASA I-II

50 (Not mentioned):

1. Midazolam group: 25

2. Ketamine group: 25

0.2 mg/kg

5 mg/kg

4-points scale

I

Hosseini Jahromi SA et al.[14]

2012

Elective surgery

2–8 yr, ASA I

60 (32/28):

1. Midazolam group: 30

2. Ketamine group: 30

0.2 mg/kg

3 mg/kg

6-points scale

I

Mostafa G et al.[21]

2013

Bone marrow biopsy and aspirate

2–8 yr, ASA II

64 (Not mentioned)

1. Midazolam group: 32

2. Ketamine group: 32

0.2 mg/kg

5 mg/kg

4-points scale

I, IV

Surendar MN et al.[22]

2014

Dental treatment

4–14 yr, ASA I

42 (Not mentioned)

1. Midazolam group: 21

2. Ketamine group: 21

0.2 mg/kg

5 mg/kg

5-points scale

I, II, III, IV

Narendra PL et al.[23]

2015

Various surgical procedures

1–10 yr, ASA II

100 (Not mentioned)

1. Midazolam group: 50

2. Ketamine group: 50

0.2 mg/kg

5 mg/kg

5-points scale

I, II, V(b,c)

Fei et al.[24]

2017

Surgery for pediatric tumors

1–3 yr, ASA I-II

60 (23/37):

1. Midazolam group: 30

2. Ketamine group: 30

0.2 mg/kg

5 mg/kg

4-points scale

I, III, IV

Akçay ME et al.[25]

2018

Ear nose throat surgical procedures

1–10 yr, ASA I-II

40 (14/26):

1. Midazolam group: 20

2. Ketamine group: 20

0.2 mg/kg

5 mg/kg

6-points scale

I, IV

Milesi C et al.[15]

2018

Non-emergent endotracheal intubation

24–36 weeks, Not mentioned

60 (25/35):

1. Midazolam group: 27

2. Ketamine group: 33

0.2 mg/kg

2 mg/kg

4-points scale comprises three domains

I, II, IV

Alp H et al.[26]

2019

Transthoracic echocardiography

9–36 mo, Not mentioned

139 (Not mentioned):

1. Midazolam group: 70

2. Ketamine group:69

0.2 mg/kg

4 mg/kg

4-points scale

I, IV, V(b,c)

Jafarnejad S et al.[27]

2020

Obtaining peripheral Intravenous (IV) line in emergency care

2–8 yr, ASA I-II

70 (35/35):

1. Midazolam group: 35

2. Ketamine group: 35

0.2 mg/kg

5 mg/kg

Observational Scale of Behavioral Distress-Revised (zero to 23.5)

I, IV

Khoshrang H et al.[28]

2021

Urologic elective surgeries

2–6 yr, ASA I-II

71 (Not mentioned):

1. Midazolam group: 35

2. Ketamine group: 36

0.5 mg/kg

5 mg/kg

5-points scale

I, III, V(b,c)

Verma I et al.[29]

2021

Elective cardiac surgery

1–12 yr, ASA II- III

60 (23/37): 1. Midazolam group: 30

2. Ketamine group: 30

0.2 mg/kg

5 mg/kg

5-points scale

I, IV, V(b)

Abusinna RG et al.[30]

2022

minor elective surgical procedures

2–9 yr, ASA I-II

100 (52/48):

1. Midazolam group: 50

2. Ketamine group: 50

0.2 mg/kg

2 mg/kg

6-points scale

I, II, IV

  1. I—Sedative effects of premedication (e.g. number of patients with satisfactory separation from parents, number of patients with satisfactory induction or mask acceptance, and number of patients with satisfactory sedation level)
  2. II—Onset of sedation
  3. III—Recovery time
  4. IV—Hemodynamic status
  5. V— Adverse effects (a. Respiratory depression and oxygen desaturation; b. Nauseas and vomiting; c. Agitation)