Skip to main content

Table 1 Rating scale for the visualization of tracheal structures and ventilation during percutaneous dilatational tracheostomy

From: Percutaneous dilatational tracheostomy with single use bronchoscopes versus reusable bronchoscopes – a prospective randomized trial (TraSUB)

 

Rating

1

2

3

4

A

Identification of thyroid cartilage, cricoid cartilage, first to third tracheal cartilage

Reliable identification

Only cricoid cartilage and tracheal cartilages

Only tracheal cartilage

No vision of tracheal structures

B

Visualization of tracheal circumference

Complete circumference

One-third to two-thirds of circumference

Only small parts of trachea

No vision of tracheal structures

C

Monitoring puncture midline + level below first or second tracheal cartilage

Reliable identification

Midline can be displayed, level uncertain, but below the first tracheal cartilage

Level of puncture uncertain

No vision of tracheal structures

D

Monitoring dilatation anterior wall and pars membranacea (p.m.) visible

Reliable identification

p.m. only

Only small parts of trachea visible, no control of p.m

No vision of tracheal structures

E

Quality of ventilation before puncture and worst ventilation during PDT, respectively

Minute ventilation (MV) as before starting PDT

MV < 2 L/minute or SpO2 80–90% (> 2 min)

MV < 0.5 L/minute or SpO2 70–79% (> 2 min)

MV = 0 or SpO2 < 70% (> 2 min)

F

Quality of suction tube for suction of viscous mucus

Easy suction

Suction requires lavage

Suction requires multiple removals of bronchoscope and lavage

Suction not possible

G

Handling of bronchoscope

easy

Impeded, all parts of the bronchial system visible

Intubation of one segment not possible

Intubation of more than one segment not possible

  1. Abbreviations: MV Minute ventilation, PDT Percutaneous dilatational tracheostomy; p.m. Pars membranacea of the trachea, SpO2 Oxygen saturation as measured by pulse oximetry
  2. Modified from Grensemann et al. [15]. Rating system: 1 = very good; 2 = good; 3 = difficult; 4 = impossible. The quality of ventilation (line E) was rated twice (i.e., before puncture [E1] and to reflect the worst ventilation during tracheostomy [E2])