Skip to main content

Table 1 Characteristics of studies included

From: Targeting urine output and 30-day mortality in goal-directed therapy: a systematic review with meta-analysis and meta-regression

Study

Total number

Type of patient

Timing

Mortality follow up

Not targeting urine output in either protocol

Sinclair 1997 [24]

40

Orthopedic

intra

30 days

Polonen 2000 [25]

393

Cardiac

post

28 days

Rhodes 2002 [26]

201

Critically ill

ICU

28 days

Pearse 2005 [27]

122

High risk

post

28 days

Szakmany 2005 [28]

40

Abdominal

Intra

3 days postoperative

Wakeling 2005 [29]

128

Abdominal

intra

30 days

Forget 2010 [30]

86

Abdominal

intra

30 days

WenKui 2010 [31]

214

Abdominal

intra, post

30 days

Cecconi 2011 [32]

40

Orthopedic

intra

28 days

Challand 2012 [33]

236

Abdominal

Intra

30 days

Bartha 2013 [34]

149

Orthopedic

intra

30 days

Bisgaard 2013 [35]

70

Abdominal

intra, post

30 days

Lai 2015 [36]

221

Abdominal

Intra

30 days

Targeting urine output only in CFM

Bishop 1995 [37]

115

Trauma

post, ICU

in-hospital (95% < 15 days)

McKendry 2004 [38]

174

Cardiac

post

30 days

Benes 2010 [39]

120

High Risk

intra

30 days

Mayer 2010 [40]

60

High Risk

Intra

in-hospital (95% < 30 days)

McKenny 2013 [41]

101

Abdominal

Intra

30 days

Zakhaleva 2013 [42]

74

Abdominal

Intra

30 days

Osawa 2016 [43]

126

Cardiac

Intra, post

30 days

Targeting urine output in both protocols

Shoemaker 1988 [44]

88

High Risk

intra, post

in-hospital (95% < 29 days)

Boyd 1993 [45]

107

High Risk

pre, intra, post, ICU

28 days

Gattinoni 1995 [46]

762

High Risk

ICU

30 days

Lobo 2000 [47]

37

High Risk

intra, post

28 days,

Rivers 2001 [48]

263

Sepsis

ICU

28 days

Chytra 2007 [49]

162

Trauma

ICU

n-hospital (75% <29 days)

Donati 2007 [50]

135

Abdominal

Intra

in-hospital (95% < 30 days)

Kapoor 2008 [51]

27

Cardiac

post

in-hospital (95% < 13 days)

Senagore 2009 [52]

43

Abdominal

Intra

2 days

Jammer 2010 [53]

241

Abdominal

intra

30 days

Jansen 2010 [54]

348

Critically ill

ICU

28 days

Jhanji 2010 [55]

135

Abdominal

post, ICU

in-hospital (75% < 28 days)

Bisgaard 2013 [56]

40

Vascular

Intra, post

30 days

Zheng 2013 [57]

60

Abdominal

Pre, intra, post

in-hospital (75% <27 days)

Peng 2014 [58]

80

Orthopedic

Intra

in-hospital (95% <28 days)

Correa-Gallego 2015 [59]

135

Abdominal

Intra, post

30 days

  1. Pre preoperative, intra intraoperative, post postoperative, ICU intensive care unit