Comparison of pressure-controlled ventilation with volume-controlled ventilation during one-lung ventilation: a systematic review and meta-analysis

Kim, Kyu Nam; Kim, Dong Won; Jeong, Mi Ae; Sin, Yeong Hun; Lee, Soo Kyung

doi:10.1186/s12871-016-0238-6

Table 1 The characteristics of the included randomized controlled trials comparing pressure-controlled ventilation with volume-controlled ventilation

From: Comparison of pressure-controlled ventilation with volume-controlled ventilation during one-lung ventilation: a systematic review and meta-analysis

					Ventilator settings
Study and year	ASA	Patients	(n)	Surgery	Tidal Volume			Target CO₂	I:E ratio	Inspiratory pause	FiO₂	PEEP (cmH₂O)	RM	Timing of RM
Study and year	ASA	Patients	(n)	Surgery	PCV	VCV	Kg	Target CO₂	I:E ratio	Inspiratory pause	FiO₂	PEEP (cmH₂O)	RM	Timing of RM
Al Shehri [29] 2014	II-III	PCV-VCV	14	Thoracotomy for lung disease	6 ml/kg	6 ml/kg	PBW	PaCO₂35-45 mmHg	1:2.5	N/D	0.5	5	Yes	At every 30 min
Al Shehri [29] 2014	II-III	VCV-PCV	14	Thoracotomy for lung disease	6 ml/kg	6 ml/kg	PBW	PaCO₂35-45 mmHg	1:2.5	N/D	0.5	5	Yes	At every 30 min
ErenOngur [27] 2010	I-II	PCV-VCV	15	Thoracotomy for lung disease	6–7 ml/kg	6 –7 ml/kg	TBW	PaCO₂35 –45 mmHg	N/D	N/D	0.5	0	Yes	Before returning to TLV
ErenOngur [27] 2010	I-II	VCV-PCV	15	Thoracotomy for lung disease	6–7 ml/kg	6 –7 ml/kg	TBW	PaCO₂35 –45 mmHg	N/D	N/D	0.5	0	Yes	Before returning to TLV
Montes [21] 2010	I-III	PCV-VCV	21	Thoracotomy for lung disease	6 ml/kg	6 ml/kg	TBW	ETCO₂25 –30 mmHg	1:3	10%	1.0	5	No
Montes [21] 2010	I-III	VCV-PCV	20	Thoracotomy for lung disease	6 ml/kg	6 ml/kg	TBW	ETCO₂25 –30 mmHg	1:3	10%	1.0	5	No
Pardos [26] 2009	N/D	PCV	55	Thoracotomy for lung disease	8 ml/kg	8 ml/kg	TBW	PaCO₂35 –40 mmHg	1:2	15%	1.0	5	Yes	At 20 min after OLV
Pardos [26] 2009	N/D	VCV	55	Thoracotomy for lung disease	8 ml/kg	8 ml/kg	TBW	PaCO₂35 –40 mmHg	1:2	15%	1.0	5	Yes	At 20 min after OLV
Tugrul M [18] 1997	I-III	PCV-VCV	24	Thoracotomy for lung disease	10 ml/kg	10 ml/kg	TBW	PaCO₂34 –45 mmHg	1:3	10%	1.0	0	No
Tugrul M [18] 1997	I-III	VCV-PCV	24	Thoracotomy for lung disease	10 ml/kg	10 ml/kg	TBW	PaCO₂34 –45 mmHg	1:3	10%	1.0	0	No
Unzueta MC [28] 2007	II-III	PCV-VCV	29	Thoracotomy for lung disease	9 ml/kg	9 ml/kg	TBW	ETCO₂30 –35 mmHg	1:2	0.9 s	1.0	0	No
Unzueta MC [28] 2007	II-III	VCV-PCV	28	Thoracotomy for lung disease	9 ml/kg	9 ml/kg	TBW	ETCO₂30 –35 mmHg	1:2	0.9 s	1.0	0	No

The respiratory rate was adjusted to maintain PaCO₂ or ETCO₂
ASA American Society of Anesthesiologists’ classification, (n) number of cases, PCV pressure-controlled ventilation, VCV, volume-controlled ventilation, I:E ratio the inspiratory to expiratory time ratio, FiO ₂ fraction of inspired oxygen, PEEP positive end-expiratory pressure, RM recruitment maneuver, PBW predicted body weight, PaCO ₂ partial pressure of carbon dioxide, ETCO ₂ end-tidal carbon dioxide, TLV two-lung ventilation, OLV one-lung ventilati on, N/D no data

Back to article page

ISSN: 1471-2253

Contact us

Submission enquiries: bmcanesthesiology@biomedcentral.com
General enquiries: ORSupport@springernature.com

BMC Anesthesiology

Contact us