|  |  |  | Selection | Comparability | Outcome | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Study | Year | Study type | NOS score | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 1 | 1 | 2 | 3 |
Beloosesky [16] | 2010 | Cohort | 6 | D | a* | a* | a* | Â | b* | a* | a* |
Wehren [23] | 2005 | Cohort | 6 | a* | a* | b* | a* | Â | b* | a* | c < 60% |
Figueiredo [24] | 2000 | Cohort | 6 | D | a* | a* | a* | Â | b* | a* | a* |
Visser [26] | 2000 | Cohort | 6 | D | a* | a* | a* | Â | b* | a* | a* |
Watters [27] | 1993 | Cohort | 7 | a* | a* | b* | a* | Â | b* | a* | a* |
Schroeder [34] | 1993 | Cohort | 6 | D | a* | b* | a* | Â | b* | a* | a* |
Griffith [28] | 1989 | Cohort | 7 | a* | a* | b* | a* | Â | b* | a* | a* |
Brenner [29] | 1989 | Cohort | 6 | D | a* | b* | a* | Â | b* | a* | a* |
Davies [32] | 1984 | Cohort | 7 | a* | a* | b* | a* | Â | b* | a* | a* |
Mahalakshmi [10] | 2004 | Case-control | 7 | a* | a* | b* | a* | b* | a* | a* | |
Cook [17] | 2001 | Case-control | 7 | a* | a* | b* | a* | b* | a* | a* | |
Le Cornu [25] | 2000 | Case-control | 7 | a* | a* | b* | a* | a* | c | a* | a* |
Guo [11] | 1996 | Case-control | 6 | a* | a* | b* | a* | Â | c | a* | a* |
Kalfarentzos [12] | 1989 | Case-control | 6 | a* | a* | b* | a* | c | a* | a* | |
Webb [30] | 1989 | Case-control | 4 | C | b | b* | a* | c | a* | a* | |
Shukla [31] | 1987 | Case-control | 6 | a* | a* | b* | a* | c | a* | a* | |
Hunt [13] | 1985 | Case-control | 4 | C | b | b* | a* | c | a* | a* | |
Klidjian [33] | 1982 | Case-control | 4 | C | b | b* | a* | c | a* | a* | |
Klidjian [9] | 1980 | Case-control | 4 | C | b | b* | a* | c | a* | a* |